NMDOJ says Otero County broke the law when it met to extend immigrant detention contract
The New Mexico Department of Justice says Otero County violated the Open Meetings Act when it approved an extension of an ICE detention contract during an emergency meeting.
State officials say the commission violated the Open Meetings Act by holding an emergency meeting to extend an ICE detention contract
Patrick Lohmann, Source New Mexico
This article was originally published by Source New Mexico.
The Otero County Commission violated the New Mexico Open Meetings Act when it held an emergency meeting March 13 to extend a contract allowing the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency to house detainees at its jail, the New Mexico Department of Justice said on Friday.
The NMDOJ review nullifies the unanimous decision commissioners made at the end of a 12-minute meeting to adopt a five-year contract extension with ICE, according to a New Mexico DOJ news release.
“The Open Meetings Act is not optional,” Attorney General Raúl Torrez said in a statement. “It ensures that public business is conducted in the open, not rushed through under the guise of an emergency when no true emergency exists.”
Otero County Attorney R.B. Nichols told commissioners on March 13 that holding an emergency meeting, which requires less public notice than regular meetings, was necessary because the county’s contract with ICE was expiring imminently.
The contract expiring would deprive the county of more than $5 million in revenue and render it unable to pay for debt service on bonds the county sold to build the Otero County Processing Center in 2007, he said.
However, the NMDOJ review found that the county had no sufficient basis to call an emergency meeting, saying it was the county’s failure to anticipate and plan for the impending contract expiration date. Emergency meetings, under OMA, can only be called due to “unforeseen circumstances,” according to the NMDOJ.
“A known contractual end date does not meet the definition of an ‘unforeseen circumstance,’” wrote Blaine Moffatt, director of the NMDOJ’s Government Counsel and Accountability Bureau, in a letter Friday to Otero County officials.
The commissioners voted to continue the contract despite a new state law, House Bill 9, that prohibits public entities like counties from contracting with federal agencies to detain immigrants. That law goes into effect May 20.
New Mexico Rep. Sarah Silva (D-Las Cruces) earlier this week asked the New Mexico Department of Justice to issue an opinion on the contract’s validity, saying she suspected it was “an attempt to circumvent HB9,” and to determine if commissioners’ lack of discussion on the contract violated state transparency laws.
Otero County Commission Chair Gerald Matherly did not immediately return SourceNM’s requests for comment Friday about the NMDOJ’s ruling or what the commission’s next steps are.
The NMDOJ earlier this year ruled that a separate county’s ICE contract extension was illegal under the Open Meetings Act. In that case, the Torrance County Commission was forced to hold a subsequent meeting, in which commissioners voted again to extend the contract.
Patrick Lohmann is a reporter for Source New Mexico.
Indivisible Las Cruces plans 'No Kings 3' rally at Albert Johnson Park on March 28 — Organizers say the March 28 event will focus on civic participation, public policy concerns and nonviolent conduct.
NMSU Library launches Loanable Technology Program to support student creativity, academic success — The program lets enrolled students borrow cameras, audio equipment and computer accessories at no cost for coursework, research and creative projects.
Woman sentenced to 10 years in prison in New Mexico after seventh federal reentry conviction — Federal prosecutors say a 60-year-old Mexican national was deported six times before receiving a 10-year prison sentence in the latest reentry case.
