Details emerge in fatal deputy shooting during Tortugas house fire

Sheriff Kim Stewart released new details Thursday about the Feb. 17 shooting in the Tortugas area, where authorities say Dylan Leonard was shot and killed after emerging with a knife during a structure fire response.

Details emerge in fatal deputy shooting during Tortugas house fire
(Courtesy photo / Doña Ana County Sheriff's Office)

Sheriff says man armed with knife advanced on deputy after refusing to leave burning home on Watson Lane

Organ Mountain News report

LAS CRUCES - New details have emerged about a fatal deputy shooting earlier this week in the Tortugas area, where authorities say a man armed with a knife was shot and killed after refusing to leave a burning home.

Doña Ana County Sheriff Kim Stewart provided an updated timeline during a Thursday news conference, outlining the events that led to the Tuesday night shooting on the 600 block of Watson Lane.

According to Stewart, Doña Ana Fire Rescue, the Doña Ana County Sheriff’s Office and the Mesilla Marshals Office responded just before 8 p.m. Tuesday to a structure fire at a single-family residence. The home had multiple points of entry and access, and firefighters began working to extinguish the blaze.

Investigators later determined the fire had been intentionally set in multiple locations on the property, Stewart said.

While crews were battling the fire, they encountered an adult male inside the residence, later identified as Dylan Leonard. Firefighters asked Leonard to leave due to the active fire, but he refused, according to the sheriff.

Firefighters then notified deputies, who attempted to communicate with Leonard through the door and repeatedly requested that he exit the structure. He continued to refuse despite the ongoing fire response, Stewart said.

With conditions inside the home becoming increasingly dangerous, deputies moved to remove Leonard from the residence.

At approximately 8:34 p.m., Leonard suddenly emerged from one of the home’s access points holding a knife and advancing toward a deputy, according to the sheriff. A Doña Ana County sheriff’s deputy and a Mesilla Marshal at the scene then fired their weapons.

Still image from an Axon body camera showing deputies inside a darkened doorway as a man raises his arm while officers illuminate him with flashlights during a nighttime response.
Dylan Leonard is seen in a still image from law enforcement body camera footage moments before he was shot and killed by deputies during a Feb. 17 response to a structure fire on Watson Lane in the Tortugas area. (Courtesy photo / Doña Ana County Sheriff’s Office)

Leonard was struck by gunfire. Deputies attempted to render medical aid, but he was pronounced dead at the scene.

One deputy sustained a minor injury during the incident and was treated and released from a local hospital.

The Officer-Involved Shooting Task Force was activated immediately after the shooting. The deputies who fired their weapons have been placed on administrative leave, which is standard procedure.

The task force — which includes investigators from the Las Cruces Police Department, Doña Ana County Sheriff’s Office, New Mexico State Police and New Mexico State University Police — is leading the investigation. Once complete, the findings will be forwarded to the Third Judicial District Attorney’s Office for review.

Keep reading:
New Mexico’s Jeffrey Epstein Truth Commission gets off the ground — Commission members hold their first meeting as the state begins examining abuse tied to Epstein’s Zorro Ranch near Stanley.
NM Legislature approves resolution for lawmaker pay, sending question to voters — Proposed constitutional amendment would let voters decide whether state lawmakers should receive salaries.
NM House passes law shielding elections from federal interference — Measure aims to limit unauthorized federal involvement in state and local election administration.

Sign up for Organ Mountain News, our free email newsletter

Get the latest headlines right in your inbox