State seeks to detain both defendants in Anthony assault case ahead of trial

Prosecutors are seeking to detain both defendants in an Anthony assault case, arguing no release conditions can protect the public following allegations of a violent confrontation.

State seeks to detain both defendants in Anthony assault case ahead of trial
(Wesley Tingey / Unsplash)

Prosecutors argue no release conditions can protect the public after alleged kidnapping and beating at gunpoint

Damien Willis, Organ Mountain News

LAS CRUCES - Prosecutors have filed motions seeking to detain both defendants charged in a violent assault case in Anthony, arguing that no release conditions can protect the public while the case proceeds.

The motions, filed April 29 in Doña Ana County Magistrate Court, ask a judge to hold Pablo Martinez, 32, and Pablo Montoya Martinez, 55, in custody pending trial.

Side-by-side booking photos of two men identified as Pablo Montoya Martinez and Pablo Martinez in front of height charts.
Pablo Montoya Martinez (left), 55, and Pablo Martinez, 32, face multiple felony charges in connection with an April 28 assault case in Anthony; prosecutors are now seeking to hold both men in custody pending pretrial detention hearings. (Courtesy photos / Doña Ana County Detention Center)

Under New Mexico law, prosecutors must show by clear and convincing evidence that a defendant poses a threat to others and that no conditions of release will reasonably protect the community.

In the filings, prosecutors argue both men pose a danger to the victim and the public, citing allegations that they forcibly pulled the victim into a vehicle, struck him multiple times with a handgun and forced their way into the victim’s home.

The motions also allege the men demanded money from a second person inside the home after kicking in a door.

Two men charged with kidnapping, assault after alleged dispute over property deal in Doña Ana County
Two men face kidnapping and assault charges after investigators say a dispute over a property transaction escalated into a violent confrontation involving a handgun in Doña Ana County.

Prosecutors say the alleged attack stemmed from a dispute over a property transaction in Anthony and escalated into a violent confrontation involving a handgun — including one defendant pointing the gun at the victim's forehead, causing him to fear for his life.

The cases stem from an incident Tuesday that led to charges including kidnapping, aggravated burglary, aggravated assault, multiple counts of aggravated battery and conspiracy to commit those offenses.

Court records show prosecutors intend to pursue grand jury indictments in the cases.

Hearings on the state's pretrial detention motions have not yet been scheduled in District Court.

Damien Willis is founder and editor of Organ Mountain News. If you have a personal story to share or a lead we should follow up on, reach out at OrganMountainNews@gmail.com or connect with him on X at @damienwillis.

Keep reading:
Police release video, new details in fatal police shooting on Lohman Avenue — Las Cruces police say video shows a man reaching for a handgun before officers opened fire during an April 24 encounter.
NMSU students build working projects in seven hours at inaugural Hack NMSU — Fifty-five students teamed up across disciplines to develop real-world solutions, including a winning project rooted in everyday nursing challenges.
Two men charged after alleged kidnapping, assault tied to Anthony property dispute — Court records detail allegations of a violent confrontation involving a handgun during a dispute over a land sale.

Cut through the noise

Sign up for our free email newsletter to receive the latest headlines from Organ Mountain News